John Kassir

Narrator (voice) / Larry / Crypt Keeper (voice)

Cam Clarke

Dudley (voice) / Bailiff (voice) / Ronald (voice) (uncredited) / Mr. Byrd's Puppet (uncredited)

Miguel Ferrer

Hitman (uncredited) (segment "As Ye Sow") / Mitch Bruckner / Gary

Sherrie Rose

Vendetta (segment "On a Deadman's Chest") / Molly (segment "Only Skin Deep")

Marshall Bell

Rock (segment "Forever Ambergris") / Husband (segment "And All Through the House")

Joe Pantoliano

Ulric (segment "Dig That Cat... He's Real Gone") / Casino Dealer (uncredited)

Lance Henriksen

Reno Crevice (segment "Cutting Cards") / Sgt. Ripper

Michael Ironside

Jerry / Sergeant Burrows

Larry Drake

Santa (segment "And All Through the House") / Tobias

William Sadler

Niles Talbot (segment "The Man Who Was Death") / The Grim Reaper

Mark Lowenthal

District Attorney (segment "The Man Who Was Death") / Doctor

Troy Evans

Al (segment "Dead Right") / Preacher